On 3 December 2009, the fourth Round Table of CONFINTEA VI addressed the topic “Assuring the Quality of Adult Education and Assessing Learning Outcomes”. Khunyin Kasam Varavarn, former Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Education in Thailand gave the keynote address. What are the lessons learned in the process and concept of Lifelong Learning, the vision which Thailand has been pursuing for over 40 years? Using concrete examples and experiences, the author works out the vision and shows the challenges as well as taking more into account the new media’s effect for the future.
The value of Lifelong Learning has long been embedded in most cultures, but the strong emphasis on attaining formal credentials has often overriden its importance. When UNESCO reignited the concept of Lifelong Learning in the late 1960s, the idea challenged educators across the globe to think beyond literacy and primary education. It also set in motion the often heated debate on whether such a concept was feasible or desirable.
While the paths to Lifelong Learning may differ from one country to another, case studies from these experiences help illustrate how the concept of Lifelong Learning gradually gains support to become the cornerstone of most education systems, some further strengthened by legislation. Furthermore, country experiences help us to understand how the seemingly elusive concept can be translated into reality.
Thailand is one of the countries that has pursued the vision of Lifelong Learning for the past forty years. While the journey continues to evolve, the lessons learned along the way can help to identify key facilitating factors as well as pitfalls to be avoided in formulating future Lifelong Learning strategies.
When the concept of Lifelong Learning was introduced in Thailand around 1970, educators were quite at loss as how to translate it into concrete actions when the country was still struggling to reach the remaining illiterate population and to provide universal primary education. While the idea was dismissed by many as unattainable and ridiculed by others, it caught the attention of adult educators who had to cope with the problems of the lack of motivation among target literacy learners. “What for?” and “what next?” were the most frequently asked questions when persuaded to join classes, as many of the learners knew from prior experiences that they could easily revert back to illiteracy due to the lack of usage.
One of the early attempts to realize the concept of Lifelong Learning in Thailand, therefore, was to propose to the government to invest in the establishment of a network of newspaper reading centers into rural, remote areas to provide continuous flows of up-to-date and interesting reading materials to the learners in the same package as the literacy program. When questioned by the Cabinet as to the necessity of such a strange and seemingly non-educational undertaking, Dr. Kowit Vorapipatna, the renowned adult educator of Thailand, convinced the non-believers by explaining that the learners would need the opportunity to use the newly acquired skills just as ”cars need to have refueling stations”.
More than forty years have elapsed since the first newspaper reading center was set up. At present, the Ministry of Education no longer finances such a center since the demands from the rural subscribers have reached the point that it is now financially viable for the publishers to operate the delivery system even to the remote areas.
Over the years, however, millions of literacy and Adult Education graduates from diverse backgrounds ranging from prominent political, business and community leaders to workers in informal sectors have generated new demands for further and continuing education. Such challenges have pressured the adult and non-formal education providers to diversify the services and bring about a series of innovations which would, in later years, influence formal schooling and the education system to review and bring about large-scale reforms.
Adult Education programs were among the first to depart from the centralized curriculum to become more learner-centered and tailor made to cater to different groups of learners. After years of continuing negotiations with the formal school system, graduates from these curricula eventually receive equivalency credentials up to higher secondary education.
In subsequent years, Adult Education programs also provide opportunities for learners to transfer life and work experiences to be accumulated and counted towards formal education equivalency credits. The involvement of non-traditional teachers, facilitators and resource persons have transformed the learning processes to take into account learners’ prior experiences and preferences with the introduction of dialogue and other interactive learning processes, bilingual approaches combining mother tongue and standard Thai language, distance education, specially designed computer and learning aids, more hands-on and project-based learning activities.
Children and youth who become ordained as Buddhist novices and study the Pali Canon can take additional classes in order to obtain basic education certificates.
Muslim youths in religious schools are acquiring basic equivalency education through learning units integrating life skills with religious teaching. Learners with disabilities who have missed their childhood education are now catching up through specially designed computer programs and learning aids.
Learners who do not speak Thai as their first language are now enjoying bilingual teaching with learning materials designed to strengthen mother tongue languages and facilitate acquisition of standard Thai.
In factories, workers are able to upgrade their basic education and skill qualifications through workplace education that allows for transfer of work experiences towards educational certificates.
In Kanchanapisek Home for Youth, youngsters with serious criminal records engage in daily analysis of real-life moral dilemmas selected from daily newspapers, practicing critical thinking, dialogues, and personal reflections in diary writing. The process has boosted their self-esteem, sharpened their critical thinking abilities, fostered moral development and
Khunying Kasama Varavarn reduced violent incidents. Source: Björn Otte, UNESCO
In prisons, educational provisions are no longer limited to basic education and skill training courses. The inmates have access to a wider range of challenging learning opportunities from well-equipped libraries, advanced courses in computer technology, fashion design, choral singing and university education.
Across the country, over 4,000 private adult education providers have registered and continue to grow in number and diversity to respond to the increasing demands from adult learners to upgrade their skills and pursue personal interests through short-term courses, correspondence schools and various forms of distance and on-line education.
During the past 70 years, Thai literacy and Adult Education has gradually expand to involve providers in all fields and touch upon the lives of the large majority of the population. It has also exerted tremendous influence on the formal school system, other development agencies, the communities and the individual learners.
The increasing number of Adult Education graduates has created not only demand for new types of education services but also new aspirations for the education of their children and their communities. Over the past decades, we have seen these demands translated into heightened participation in education and pressures for reforms from the civil society. The concept of Lifelong Learning gradually penetrates formal schooling, the way of thinking of the educators and the country as a whole.
While Lifelong Learning first made its impact in the areas of literacy and Adult Education, around 1974, the report of the education reform committee entitled Education for Life clearly advocated that the entire education system be developed to insure Lifelong Learning through synergy among formal, non-formal, and informal education.
By 1999, when the Thai parliament passed the influential Education Act, lifelong education was mandated as the basic guiding principle and the goal of the education system. The architects of the Education Act were so concerned that the entire educational provisions be based on Lifelong Learning that they decided to merge the offices of adult and non-formal education and formal education together under the management of the newly created Office of Basic Education.
This decision led to nationwide protests among Adult Education providers and supporters who feared that the distinct nature of adult and non-formal education would be under the shadow of the powerful school system. As a result, the government decided to reinstate the Office of Non-Formal Education as an independent organization, not under the wing of the Office of Basic Education. Nine years later, the parliament promulgated the Non-Formal and Informal Education Act with the aim to mobilize all government agencies and all sectors of the society towards realization of the vision of Lifelong Learning.
It is important to note that the close cooperation among formal and non-formal education that flourished before the Education Act, subsided during the merging policy and resumed soon after both offices regained their independent and equivalent status. Some of the concrete examples resulting from close linkages between formal and non-formal education are as follows:
Revision of the national basic education curriculum from centralized curriculum for all learners to standard based curriculum with provisions for locally relevant contents to serve the diverse groups of learners.
Development of self-directed learners with critical thinking and problem solving abilities, fundamental learning skills and metacognitive abilities became the primary aims of basic education. The once all-important contents now became recognized as means through which self-learning skills could be enhanced.
Action and experiential learning initiated in non-formal education are now common practices in formal schools through community service programs, internships and apprenticeship with local workplace, part-time employment, small scale student-run enterprises, cross registration among formal and non-formal programs, all of which can be transferred for credits.
Schools are encouraged to offer alternative pathways for learners with special needs, combining the better equipped facilities and personnel of the schools with the more flexible non-formal education curricula, inclusive admission policies and regulations, and specially designed support facilities for groups with special needs. As a result, a vast number of drop-outs, out-of-school youth and adults are returning to the schools and universities, altering the student profiles and enriching the learning environment.
Teachers have also benefitted from innovations first piloted in non-formal education. On-line training programs and distance education once catered primarily to adult learners are adopted to train teachers on a nationwide basis. One noteworthy effort was initiated by HRH Princess Sirindhorn to assist teachers from ethnic backgrounds who work with preschool children in mountainous regions to obtain university degrees and teaching certificates through distance education. Teachers also form professional learning groups to upgrade their competencies through sharing of knowledge and experiences, coaching, mentoring and various forms of knowledge management techniques.
The universities have also been influenced by adult and non formal education, initially, by the new demands for higher education from the massive number of Adult Education graduates. While the two major open universities, Sukothai Thammatiraj and Ramkamhang Universities, were among the first to accommodate such demands, soon after, many other universities adopted open admission policies which embrace adult learners and learners with special needs. The inclusive admission policies, in turn, bring about more inclusive teaching and learning practices, more flexible transfer of prior learning towards credits, more responsive regulations and codes of conducts for students and deeper understanding of the principles of andragogy among formal school teachers and university faculty members.
To respond to the diverse, participatory and learner centered educational strategy, the structure of the education system has been decentralized to school level and operational units with members of the communities, parents and alumni serving on the increasingly powerful school boards and school district committees. Adult Education and non-formal education have been called upon to assist parents and school boards to develop greater understanding about child rearing practices, new issues confronting todays’ youth and their contribution to the education of their children. Within the schools, student clubs and student councils are now widespread, empowered by the participatory techniques of adult and non-formal education.
Close linkages between formal and non-formal education have yielded mutual benefits. Capital intensive infrastructure invested for the school system such as the nation-wide Internet connection, educational radio and television broadcasting facilities, water systems, school libraries, laboratories and sports facilities, have been fully utilized for adult and non-formal education programs, community based learning activities as well as the universities reaching out to learners in rural areas. Adult learners have also benefitted from policies originally formulated for school students, such as the supports for free tuition and free text books for those engaged in all forms of basic education. Universities with extension services have contributed to the wealth of knowledge on Adult Education, served as strong advocates of Lifelong Learning policies and developed new generations of lifelong learners.
Working in complement with each other, formal and non-formal education have greatly inculcated the culture of Lifelong Learning, enriched the learning opportunities and contributed towards the strengthening of Lifelong Learning.
The impact of Lifelong Learning reaches far beyond the realm of the Ministry of Education. Other development agencies have long worked with communities and adult groups to upgrade their skills and competencies. Although they may not identify their work as adult non-formal education nor Lifelong Learning, knowledge and skills acquired through these activities can be transferred for credits. Coordination among the various agencies is achieved though the Ministerial Level National Coordinating Committee for Promotion and Support of Non-Formal and Informal Education.
The military, one the biggest providers, constantly upgrades training programs for new draftees to insure that they leave the service with literacy skills, basic education and fundamental vocational skills.
The Ministry of Public Health recruits close to one million health volunteers to serve every village of the country with continuous training programs which can be counted towards basic education certificates. These volunteers, in turn, work with the schools and organize health-related activities in the communities. Some of their most spectacular achievements include campaigns to improve public toilets of the country and to organize community-based aerobic exercise. Such activities have greatly influenced not only the health habits but also the learning behaviors of the population as a whole.
The Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives operates a network of extension workers in various fields related to agriculture across the country as well as farmers cooperatives, imparting exemplary practices and enriching the indigenous learning systems within the community.
Source: Björn Otte, UNESCO
The Border Police initially trained village scouts for security and development purposes. Over the years, the membership grew to several million and became recognized as a powerful social movement, supported by various government agencies to enhance their knowledge, skills, and participation.
There are now several thousands non-governmental agencies and communitybased organizations working in educational and development projects. Chai Pattana Foundation and Thai Rice Foundation under Royal Patronage, for example, established the first Farmer School in the province of Ayudhaya to provide opportunities for the farmers and extension workers to meet, share experiences and conduct experimentation in order to compare the benefits of traditional and new ways of rice farming. The school succeeds in disseminating more effective farming practices and in generating learning groups within the community. A few years later, the Foundation set up another school to revive the use of buffaloes for tilling the land.
Unlike other member states, support from local government, which now receives over 30 percent of budget allocations, however, is still limited, since their priority is placed on preschool and formal education. Inspired by the business sector and examples from other countries, the Bangkok Metropolitan Authority has declared the goal to become a Learning City and many local governments are investing in libraries and learning resource centers.
The concept of Lifelong Learning has also influenced the business sector. In an attempt to meet the challenges of globalization, business corporations have placed priority on human resource development and on creating learning organizations.
The active participation of the business community brings new perspectives to adult and non-formal education that hitherto, have been predominantly community and basic education based. The new adult learners are now university graduates with international exposure and standards. The organizers are business executives and industrialists. The money invested per trainee far exceeds most provision provided by previous literacy and Adult Education programs. Sophisticated training techniques are adopted from more developed economies or created by universities funded to conduct research and development.
Once the human resource development system is in place, many companies move on to Corporate Social Responsibility projects to utilize their resources and personnel to contribute to the development of schools and the communities, resulting in fascinating synergy between business and community-based wisdom.
The Siam Cement Group is an example of a conglomerate that places priority on the value of the people and was the first to establish a human resource management unit. Mr. Paron Issarasena, the former CEO who served for eight years as the company’s Human Resource Manager believed that
“our personnel is our most valuable asset. The more competent, knowledgeable and ethical people we have in our company, the more effective we can move towards our goal. Our company can only survive on two critical factors: our human resource and technology. Not to invest in people is to go against the fundamental business principle.”
Mr. Paron later founded the Suksapattana Foundation which supported satellite transmitted educational programs and worked with Massachusetts Institute of Technology to introduce the concept of Constructionism to Thai schools and the communities.
The Thai government has carried out many proactive measures to mobilize the support of the business sector to invest in human resource development. Expenses incurred in training of personnel or in supporting schools receive double tax deductions. Campaigns are launched to invite companies to “adopt” schools or libraries and to provide scholarships for students and teachers. Krung Thai Bank adopts 97 schools and assigns executives and board members to supervise the assistance rendered to each school.
The mass media have been most instrumental in facilitating Lifelong Learning. A survey has found that on the average, Thai people spend more than four hours watching television and listening to the radio. Close to 60 percent of the Thai population aged 15-59 read a newspaper every day. In order to counteract the commercial influences dominating the media, several measures have been undertaken. These include, inter alia, provision in the education act to provide a free educational broadcasting frequency, trust funds set up from earnings from telecommunication monopoly fees to develop “edutainment programs”, establishment of a public broadcasting television station, and time allocated to children and educational programs during prime time.
The use of communication technology is also transforming the learning styles of the Thai population. In 2008, mobile phone, computer and Internet users accounted for 52 percent, 28 percent and 18 percent of the population respectively. The Internet users alone increased from 220,000 in 1997 to 13,146,000 in 2007. The 2008 survey also indicates serious digital divisions among people of different regions, age groups and educational backgrounds. Bangkok residents have the highest usage at 36 percent, while only 13-18 percent of those living in other re-gions are Internet users. Close to 70 percent of university graduates use the Internet while 29 percent and 6 percent of secondary school and primary school graduates do so. Similarly, around 78 percent of professionals use the Internet compared to 2 percent among farmers. Among women who have attained educational parity with men, a lower percentage have experience using e-commerce.
Since 2005, the Thai government has tried to improve accessibility by connecting all schools with the Internet. While the project has greatly transformed learning and teaching processes in schools as well as facilitated the use of the Internet in the communities, much more needs to be done to bridge the widening gaps.
Among the Internet users, entertainment and games account for 50 percent of usage compared with only 8 percent for news and education. To insure that the wider access to the Internet will be utilized for meaningful learning experiences, the Ministry of Culture along with the Ministry of Education and Ministry of Technology and many non-governmental agencies have carried out several innovative measures. These include the promotion of “Good Internet Cafés” which agree to use creative and educational software and adhere to strict regulation on the usage by children and youth, training of youth in computer programming including those who have become game addicts, support for Thai language educational websites, training in media and computer literacy to foster responsible and ethical usage of computers, programs to educate parents to keep track of computer usage of their children and development of screening devices and mechanisms.
The ultimate support for Lifelong Learning comes from the communities, learning groups and the individual learners themselves who generate new demands for learning opportunities, offer their own services as resource persons or organizers and contribute towards the development of Lifelong Learning culture.
Some notable case studies help to illustrate how communities, groups and individual learners have been transformed by Lifelong Learning, and they in turn serve as catalysts for enriching Lifelong Learning opportunities.
With over 30,000 temples and 400,000 monks across Thailand, the Buddhist institution is potentially the most powerful educational delivery system of the country. Over the years, however, the school systems and the mass media have taken over the prominent roles in educating the Thai public.
Within the past few years, new and exciting innovations have emerged in the teaching of Buddhism and proved to be highly successful in renewing public interest. These approaches include, inter alia, production of attractive publications with colorful illustration, down to earth writing style, dealing with topics close to the concern of youth and the general public, the use of animation, text message and music to convey Buddhist concepts, training of monks to teach in schools and to conduct their sermons more effectively and campaign to ordain youngsters as novices or to form voluntary groups for community services.
With the shift in the age structure of the society, the aging population is now receiving a great deal of attention with concrete plans to provide a variety of services as well as to utilize their expertise. The Brain Bank organization, for example, has been set up to mobilize retired academicians and scholars to provide advice and voluntary consulting services.
OPPY: Old People Playing Young Group was founded eight years ago by a prominent business woman at the age of 70 with the aims to encourage and assist people over the age of 45 to learn to use the Internet. The project has grown into a club with over 3,000 active members who join to pursue other learning activities such as photography and water colour painting. The project was among the first to recognize and try to bridge the gap between the older generation and the skills required to function effectively in society.
Among the communities that have turned around as a result of Lifelong Learning, Limtong Village is perhaps most well known. The village is situated in Buriram Province in rich and fertile land with a huge swamp providing the village with fresh water and an abundant supply of fish. Over the years, the swamp gradually dried up, making rice farming increasingly difficult. At the same time, new roads brought in luxury goods and opportunities to migrate from the communities. With fewer helping hands and lower communal spirit, the villagers stopped helping each other and had to hire outsiders during farming season. Soon, most families were in heavy debt.
Several agencies started to assist the community to transform on the principles of self-sufficiency bestowed by His Majesty King Bhumipol. Suksapattana Foundation was the first to help with agriculture activities, Auntie Noy, a lower primary school graduate, learned to keep a family account. She soon discovered that the large majority of their expenses went into alcohol and gambling. Auntie Noy vowed to stop buying lottery tickets and helped her husband to get rid of his drinking habits. Soon the family saved enough money to invest in improving their soil for vegetable farming. Auntie Noy went on to learn computer skills through which she became aware of the fluctuating prices of vegetables in the different markets and learned of new varieties of cash crops, new production, marketing, and management techniques.
Meanwhile, the entire village was inspired by Auntie Noy’s determination and followed her example in keeping account of their spending. Eventually, the entire village succeeded in cutting down their gambling and drinking and saved enough money to open a community grocery store. The success of the grocery store motivated the community to move on to other development activities such as community computer center, the use of GPS to survey the landscape and identify appropriate sites for water canals serving the entire village and preparation of village production and marketing plan. While the village received assistance from many agencies, the key to the success lies in the transformation of each individual learner and the community to become self-directed learners, continually seeking, sharing, experimenting and disseminating new knowledge.
At the individual level, Sunan Sangsuwan, founder of an Export Pottery Factory, represents another self-directed learner who became a millionaire from her determination to learn. Upon her graduation from the university with a social science degree, Ms Sunan ran a family owned catering service with little success. Noticing the interest of foreign visitors of the local pottery, she began a small souvenir shop selling local products. When the business proved to be more successful than the catering service, Ms. Sunan took an intensive English class, learning just enough to communicate for the export of pottery. The first three years of her business were devoted to learning and experimentation on every dimension of the business, from management, export business, financial management, personnel management, production techniques, and the lifestyles of potential customers in foreign lands. Ms. Sunan now runs a factory employing 300 workers, all of whom receive on-the-job training, exporting over 5 million US dollars worth of pottery to 26 countries each year. She attributes her success to “the unceasing desire to learn and to teach”.
These success stories are growing in number, portraying that Lifelong Learning is no longer confined to policy statement or government initiated activities but has affected the lives of people at all levels of the society. The value of Lifelong Learning, once embedded in most cultures, is now regaining its strengths. It is important to recognize, however, that promising as these case studies may seem, they are only isolated examples. If Lifelong Learning is to serve as a powerful vehicle for development, lessons from past experiences must be examined and new challenges emerging must be foreseen.
Women Working Group
Source: Claudia Ferreira
Thailand’s forty years of experience in pursuing Lifelong Learning illustrate its dynamism. From continuing education for literacy and Adult Education graduates, Lifelong Learning now encompasses a rich diversity of learning opportunities extending far beyond the education sector into the communities, business sector and overall social and economic development arena. The key strategies and facilitating factors have included the following:
1. The need to reaffirm our commitment to serve the educationally disadvantaged
With increased enrolment rates and progress towards achieving education for all targets, pressure towards searching for and reaching the educationally disadvantaged has been vastly reduced. The new marginalized groups are often overlooked, especially those left out by advancement in technology, those endangered by armed conflicts and those affected by the continuing education for adult graduates to encompass all segments of the society has greatly shifted the program’s priorities. It is quite likely that once again the needs of the educationally disadvantaged will be secondary to the needs of the better endowed and high profile learners. It is important to insure that Lifelong Learning continues to serve as the tool to help bridging and not widening the opportunity gaps within society.
Source: Björn Otte, UNESCO
2. The threats and the benefits of technology in insuring equitable Lifelong Learning
While Thailand has allocated a significant proportion of the budget to equip schools and education facilities with Internet and new technology, it has not been able to tackle the problem of the digital divide. Furthermore, the new technology has not been fully harnessed to benefit the educationally disadvantaged. Inadequate preparation has also led to wasteful and harmful utilization among the learners. Unless more effective strategy can be formulated to handle this critical challenge, technology will undoubtedly become the key deciding factor on the issue of equity and quality in the future.
3. The search for a more appropriate concept of quality
The education system based on the principles of Lifelong Learning has brought about more diversified learning goals and approaches with transfer of credits across programs organized by different providers, alternative pathways to serve the diverse groups of learners, and more tailor-made curricula. There is a need to review and reformulate the working definition of quality to attain a balance between standards required and flexibility in response to the diverse needs and conditions of the learners.
4. Preparing for the new players of Lifelong Learning
Over the years, facilitators of Lifelong Learning have extended beyond those involved in literacy and Adult Education. Active participation has arisen from the schools, universities, communities, business corporations, mass media, religious institutions, social, cultural or even political movements. These new players brought with them new resources and approaches which have further enriched and expanded the vision of Lifelong Learning. In most cases, however, the new players do not consider their work as adult or non-formal education. Coming from vastly different backgrounds, they do not share the same ideology and often lack the abilities to work effectively with disadvantaged adults. Adult educators, at the same time, are often concerned about the newcomers and feel the need to control directions and goals. There is an urgent need, therefore, to establish a mechanism to mobilize participation, develop sense of ownership, and provide opportunities for learning and sharing so that synergy between the diverse groups of Lifelong Learning facilitators can be achieved.
5. Fostering moral and ethical development through Lifelong Learning
While Lifelong Learning has proved to be effective in enhancing literacy and communication skills, for upgrading educational qualifications or preparing for the world of work, its success in transforming the ethical values and the behavior of the learners is much more limited. The commercial sector, on the other hand, has fully exploited the power of the mass media and informal education in creating new and often unnecessary demands among the consumers. Greater attention must be given to foster moral and ethical development, responsible global awareness and empower our learners for social causes through Lifelong Learning.
Thailand is proud to have made some significant progress in realizing the vision of Lifelong Learning. We feel indebted to UNESCO and international organizations for inspiration and support, to UIL for expanding the concept and the network of Lifelong Learning, to member states for exemplary practices. Even though we have much to celebrate, we are acutely aware that the road ahead is even more challenging. CONFINTEA VI is organized at the crucial moment when we need to harness all our wisdom to cope with the increasingly detrimental global issues. It is our hope that CONFINTEA VI will serve as a venue through which we can assess the present situation, review our ongoing practices and pave the way for future Lifelong Learning strategy to unleash the human potentials for sustainable development.
You can search for articles in our article index (sorted by authors, issues, year, regions and countries). It also provides a full text search.
The journal Adult Education and Development is distributed free of charge in English, French and Spanish. If you wish to receive the journal, please subscribe here.